Wrapping Brisket: Butcher Paper vs Foil vs No Wrap

Close-up of a hand slicing juicy, smoked beef brisket on a wooden cutting board, showcasing deliciously cooked meat.

Written by

Outdoor Cooking King

in

Wrapping a brisket partway through the cook is common, but the sources disagree about whether to use butcher paper or foil, and some skip the wrap altogether. This guide sets out what Meathead Goldwyn at AmazingRibs.com, MasterClass’s write-up of Aaron Franklin, Texas Monthly, a report from Texas A&M’s Camp Brisket and Smoked BBQ Source say about each approach, and why. Celsius conversions are ours.

What Wrapping Is For

Meathead credits wrapping with beating the stall, minimizing evaporative cooling, shortening the cook and keeping juices. Texas A&M’s Camp Brisket, as reported by The Virtual Weber Bullet, describes the stall as evaporative cooling at the meat surface that usually halts the internal temperature somewhere between 140 and 160°F (60 to 71°C). The reported advice was to wrap once the meat reaches about 160°F (71°C). Meathead wraps at 150 to 165°F (66 to 74°C), and Smoked BBQ Source at 165°F (74°C) or when the stall hits, after a dark bark forms.

Butcher Paper

Franklin wraps with uncoated butcher paper, according to MasterClass, because it is more breathable and traps less steam, keeping the meat moist without making the bark soggy. His method wraps in the fourth stage of a 12-hour, six-stage cook. Meathead says paper cuts about 1 hour off the cook and lets some moisture escape, but adds that it tastes very much like the foil version and that the differences are subtle. The Camp Brisket report says peach paper is not air- or water-tight like foil, which is said to avoid foil’s pot-roast flavor. A survey presented there by Jess Pryles found almost all the restaurants surveyed used butcher paper. Pitmaster John Brotherton said most restaurants wrap around 170°F (77°C); wrapping at 160°F (71°C) leaves more hot liquid in the paper, a burn hazard.

Foil

Meathead says foil gives moister meat with a slight pot-roast texture and softer bark, and can cut 2 hours off the cook. The Camp Brisket report says every competition team surveyed wrapped in foil, and that Snow’s BBQ foils about two-thirds of the way through the cook. Meathead’s numbers are a plan of 14 to 18 hours in foil including a 2-hour hold, with an extra 1 to 2 hours for paper.

The Foil Boat

Texas Monthly’s Daniel Vaughn describes a middle option from pitmaster Evan LeRoy: foil shaped around the bottom and sides, with the fat-cap top left open. LeRoy says it gives a crunchy bark while the meat sits in its own juices. In a blind panel tasting at Goldee’s Barbecue that also included paper-wrapped brisket, Vaughn preferred the foil-boat bark and says he was not alone. It was a tasting panel, not a controlled study. LeRoy’s caveat is storage, since boats cannot be stacked in a warmer like paper-wrapped briskets.

No Wrap

MasterClass says an unwrapped brisket gives a crunchier bark but needs care to avoid drying out. Smoked BBQ Source says it takes longer, with more smoke and a bark with real crunch. Meathead plans 16 to 20 hours of cooking plus the hold. Franklin’s 2011 Texas Monthly instructions for home cooks do not describe a wrap step.

Does It Matter?

Evidence is thin. The Virtual Weber Bullet’s Camp Brisket report says a final wrapped-versus-unwrapped tasting was held, and that the author had read that past classes found no significant difference in “overall like” scores; he did not see the scores himself. Smoked BBQ Source describes a single test cook by T-Roy Cooks at 225°F: 9 hours for foil, 10 for paper and 11 for unwrapped, with the foil brisket judged most tender and moist, and the unwrapped one judged to have the best bark and strongest smoke. That is one cook on one smoker, not a controlled trial.

Holding Safely After a Wrap

Wrapping makes holding easy. Meathead holds until the meat falls back to 150°F (66°C), about 2 to 4 hours. Brotherton holds at 145°F (63°C) for several hours, and Camp Brisket advised slicing at 140 to 150°F (60 to 66°C). USDA says hot food should stay at or above 140°F (60°C) and cooked food should not be left out over 2 hours, or 1 hour above 90°F (32°C). A cooler hold near those numbers is worth checking with a thermometer. Note that brisket’s 195 to 205°F finish is about tenderness: Meathead says these cuts are safe at 145°F, and USDA’s minimum for beef roasts and steaks is 145°F (63°C) with a 3-minute rest.

Keep reading

Sources

More posts