The Regions of Texas Barbecue, and Who Draws the Map

A mouthwatering platter of grilled meat, rice, and corn on a lace tablecloth.

Written by

Outdoor Cooking King

in

Ask five people how many barbecue regions Texas has and you may get five answers. Writers and historians agree that Texas barbecue is not one uniform thing, but they draw the map differently. This article lays out the classifications as stated by Texas Monthly’s Daniel Vaughn, the Southern Foodways Alliance, the Texas Almanac and others, and leaves the disagreements visible.

There Is No Single Official Map

A 2019 Texas State University honors thesis by Austin Crane, a student paper rather than a reference work, says arguments can be made for between five and seven barbecue regions in Texas. It cites Robb Walsh’s The Legends of Texas Barbecue for five and Daniel Vaughn and Nicholas McWhirter’s The Prophets of Smoked Meat for seven, and itself works with six: Panhandle, West, South, Central, East and North Texas. It also stresses that the regions are vernacular and loosely bounded.

Robert Moss, a Charleston food writer, offered a shorter list in a 2013 response that Texas Monthly published on its site: at least four styles, namely East Texas, Central Texas, barbacoa and the West Texas cowboy style. The Texas Almanac takes a wider view, dividing Texas cuisine as a whole, not barbecue alone, into five culinary regions.

Central Texas

Vaughn, writing for the Southern Foodways Alliance, says Central Texas barbecue was born in the meat markets of late-nineteenth-century Texas, many run by owners of Czech and German heritage who brought sausage-making traditions. The name, he says, comes from the two oldest barbecue joints in Texas still serving that style, Kreuz Market in Lockhart (open since 1900) and Southside Market in Elgin, both in Central Texas, although he notes that meat markets serving barbecue were found across the state, at least where Europeans settled, before 1900. He also reports that the first advertisement for barbecue sold in America came from a butcher in Bastrop in 1878. He describes its core as wood as the only fuel, a salt, pepper and cayenne seasoning, indirect heat, and meat sold by the pound on butcher paper.

The Texas Almanac, in an article by Dotty Griffith, places the barbecue belt in towns like Taylor, Luling, Lockhart and Elgin, and says German, Czech and Polish immigrants arrived in the decades around the Civil War, with butcher shops and smokehouses turning into barbecue emporiums. It names pecan and oak as common woods and calls the region the land of dry spice rubs.

Vaughn adds a caution: the label “Central Texas” is now used broadly in and outside Texas for a newer big-city style with premium meats and sides, which he calls usually a misnomer.

Hill Country, Llano and the West

The Texas State thesis reports that Vaughn distinguishes Central Texas from Hill Country barbecue, with Central Texas using low, slow indirect smoking, usually with post oak, and Hill Country using more direct heat over mesquite coals. A 1992 Texas Monthly article by John Morthland describes exactly that in Llano: mostly mesquite, logs burned down to coals in a separate firebox, and meat that locals say is cooked rather than smoked, “the way the cowboys did it.” He contrasts it with most of the Hill Country, which he says uses the Czech-German pit-smoking method. Moss’s list calls the direct-heat tradition the West Texas cowboy style and names Walter Jetton, who cooked whole steers over open pits, as its best-known figure. The Texas Almanac’s “Cowboy Country” section on the Panhandle plains describes chuck-wagon fare and steaks, not a barbecue method.

East Texas

The Almanac says East Texas barbecue reflects more Southern and African-American traditions, often with a sweeter sauce than the Hill Country, and that mops and basting marinades carry much of the seasoning there. The Texas State thesis, drawing on Walsh, calls it a variant of Black Southern barbecue, centered on pork ribs and pork sausage, and says it is often without rubs or sauce. Those two descriptions do not fully agree on sauce. The thesis also quotes Vaughn calling Texas Monthly’s brisket-based rating system, anchored in Central Texas joints, an outdated way of thinking, in a passage about East Texas pitmasters being overlooked.

South Texas and Barbacoa

In a 2015 Texas Monthly piece, Vaughn describes barbacoa de cabeza en pozo, beef heads cooked with wood coals in underground pits, as a form of Texas barbecue rooted in the Rio Grande Valley. He says the area became part of Texas after the Mexican-American War in 1848, and that beef-head barbacoa became the barbecue dish of choice there. In 2015 he named Vera’s Backyard Bar-B-Que in Brownsville as the only restaurant left in Texas still cooking whole heads in the ground.

His article also records a classification dispute: after Texas Monthly’s 2013 Top 50 list, food editor Patricia Sharpe explained that barbacoa is its own category, while a critic answered that the magazine had built a rhetorical border fence around Texas barbecue. The Texas State thesis instead folds barbacoa into a South Texas region that also serves brisket, ribs and sausage.

Contested Origins

The sources also date the tradition differently. Moss says Texans have cooked barbecue only since around 1840; Vaughn’s 1878 Bastrop advertisement concerns commercial sale; the Almanac ties the German tradition to immigration beginning in the early 1800s; and Vaughn says barbacoa in the Valley predates the state. They answer different questions, and none settles them.

Keep reading

Sources

More posts